1. Summary of Legal Issues and Practical Implementation The balance between host-state regulatory autonomy (particularly regarding national defense, security, and public health) and the legitimate expectations of foreign investors under International Investment Agreements (IIAs) presents complex jurisdictional challenges.
- Origin of Legal Duties: When admitting foreign investment, host states must observe investment protection standards—such as Fair and Equitable Treatment (FET) and Non-Discrimination—under bilateral investment treaties (BITs) and new-generation free trade agreements (e.g., CPTPP, EVFTA), while applying domestic investment scrutiny.
- Common Violations and Practical Risks:
- Sudden policy changes, retroactive regulatory shifts, or revocation of investment certificates without reasonable transition periods or compensation.
- Ambiguity in domestic security appraisal processes leading to protracted administrative delays or discriminatory denials of market access.
- High exposure of the host state to investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS) arbitration claims at ICSID or UNCITRAL tribunals.
2. Core Applicable Legal Provisions
- 2.1. Market Access and National Security Conditions: Article 9 and Article 22 of the Law on Investment 2020 restrict market entry and impose conditional investment requirements on foreign investors, mandating security appraisals for projects involving land use in border, coastal, and strategically sensitive areas.
- 2.2. State Investment Guarantees: Articles 10, 11, and 13 of the Law on Investment 2020 ensure non-discrimination, protection of property rights, and statutory guarantees against retroactive legislative changes affecting investment incentives.
- 2.3. International Investment Standards: The FET standard and Indirect Expropriation protections codified across international treaties (e.g., Article 9.6 of the CPTPP, Chapter 8 of the EVFTA, and the EU-Vietnam Investment Protection Agreement – EVIPA).
3. Legal Consequences and Sanctions
- International Arbitral Awards: If a state agency’s administrative measures violate FET or constitute indirect expropriation, international arbitral tribunals may order the host state to pay millions of dollars in damages under ICSID or UNCITRAL rules.
- Administrative Annulment: Investment registrations obtained via fraudulent declarations or in breach of national defense restrictions are subject to project termination under Article 48 of the Law on Investment 2020.
4. Legal Commentary and Evaluation
- 4.1. Impact on Business and Investment: A predictable, transparent investment screening regime prevents costly international litigation while safeguarding national sovereignty and critical infrastructure assets.
- 4.2. Practical Difficulties and Solutions: Lack of precise statutory definitions for “national security” in the Law on Investment creates discretion-heavy reviews. The state needs clear, published operational guidelines for national security appraisals to minimize subjective administrative roadblocks.
5. Conclusion and Practical Recommendations
- Foreign investors must conduct thorough regulatory and land-use due diligence before acquisition, verifying location compliance under local defense master plans.
- State administrative bodies should standardize consultation procedures and respect legitimate investor expectations during public policy transitions.
TLA Law is a leading legal firm with an experienced team of attorneys and legal professionals specializing in criminal law, civil law, corporate law, marriage and family law, and more. We are ready to support and resolve any of your legal inquiries. If you have any further questions regarding this matter, please feel free to contact us immediately for assistance.
Lawyer Vu Thi Phuong Thanh, Chairwoman of the Members’ Council, TLA Law LLC (Hanoi Bar Association) – Email: vtpthanh@tlalaw.vn
Lawyer Tran My Le, Managing Director, TLA Law LLC (Hanoi Bar Association) – Email: tmle@tlalaw.vn
Address: 7th Floor, No. 6 Duong Dinh Nghe Street, Yen Hoa, Hanoi, Vietnam
Website: https://tlalaw.vn/
Hotline: 0904 267 027
Vu Thuy Linh